A Master's Thesis, September 1993  in English
Mei-ling Lu
The Potential Impact of the Modern Literal Taiwanese in Latin Alphabet on the Ethnic Identity and Communication Among the Taiwanese People
Approved by Professor Dr. Julia R.Dobrow and Professor Joanna White
School of Mass Communication and Public Relations
College of Communication, Boston University

  --> Prospects-0 EDUTECH-T

Contents: Acknowledgement       Preface      Abstract
____Chap-1.  Statement of the Problem     Chap-2.  Literature Review
____ Chap-3.  Methodology           Chap-4.  Results of the Interview
____ Chap-5.  Analysis and Conclusion        Chap-6.  Discussion

Acknowledgement

Preface
     ___
     ___It was in the end of August, 1991, when I came to the United States to
     ___
attend Boston University and temporarily lived in my cousin's home in
     ___
Brookline, that I first learned this Latin alphabetic writing system of my native
     ___
Taiwanese language.    Like most of the people in Taiwan, in my opinion,
     ___
Taiwanese was a vernacular without a complete written form and served for
UP
only daily conversation.
   ___
     ___I was astonished at and excited about the capability and completeness of
     ___
this writing system in conveying the beauty of my native language, both in sound
     ___
and sense.    In recalling the various Taiwanese ballads heard from my now dead
     ___
grandmother in my childhood, I always felt pity that this literature would be lost
     ___
someday, owing to no appropriate written form to convey the language.    And
     ___
there is one now!
   ___
     ___I had a chance to join a study group on this writing system in January,
     ___
1992.     Later, in July, 1992, in the Taiwanese American Conference/East Coast
     ___
held in Amherst, MA,    I further had opportunities to go to the two lectures of
     ___
Dr. Keahioong Liim (Chi-hsiung Lin), the advocate of this writing system and
UP
author of Taiwanese Dictionary of Words with Modern Spelling.      In the
     ___
lectures Dr. Liim pointed out the importance and necessity of language
     ___
modernization and internationalization, and that it is through the sensational
     ___
development of the human mind that human beings are able to emancipate their
     ___
inner feelings.    This process of mental emancipation is usually completed
     ___
through the language which people have acquired since their infant stage from
     ___
their parents and families; i.e. their mother tongue.    On the other hand,
     ___
languages acquired after schooling serve largely for intellectual and academic
     ___
functions.    It is therefore important for those who speak Taiwanese to have
UP
an appropriate written form as a channel to express their feelings and thoughts.
   ___
     ___I was mainly inspired by these two lectures to write this thesis.
     ___
Furthermore, as a communication major, I am interested in how this writing
     ___
system might impact the Taiwanese people culturally and technologically.    This
     ___
thesis will, therefore, investigate the potential impact of this writing system which
     ___
is the written form of the mother tongue of the largest population in Taiwan on
     ___
the ethnic identity of the Taiwanese people, as well as its potentiality in
     ___
computational data processing systems.
UP


Abstract

The Potential Impact of the Modern Literal
Taiwanese in Latin Alphabet on the Ethnic Identity
and Communication among the Taiwanese People

by
Mei-ling Lu, M.S.

School of Mass Communication and Public Relations
College of Communication Boston University
September, 1993

Thesis Advisor: Dr. Julia, R. Dobrow, Assistant Professor

   _Language is a primary channel of human communication;  it is the most
UP
expressive form of culture and a basic feature of ethnicity in human society.
     _
It was suggested in manystudies that there are close links between language and
   _
ethnic identity, between written language and the construction of socio-cultural
   _
norm, and among language, writing, and the emancipation of human feelings.
     _
There are also arguments demonstrating thesignificance of efficiency of writing
     _
in data communication.    Many researchers have pointed out that the impact of
     _
the interactions among these factors on human communication is tremendous,
     _
both socio-culturally and technologically.
   _
   _This study was an investigation adopting the above arguments into the
     _
context of the Modern Literal Taiwanese, a Latin-alphabetical written form of the
     _
mother tongue of about 80% of the population in Taiwan, to explore how it
     _
might affect the ethnic identity and communication among the Taiwanese
UP
people.
   _
   _The research methodology used in this study was a combination of intensive
     _
interviews and critical analysis.   In the interviews, 3 major advocators of the
     _
Modern Literal Taiwanese, 2 teachers of this writing system, and 2 teachers
     _
teaching junior high school Chinese in Taiwan were interviewed.    In addition
     _
to the background information about the Modern Literal Taiwanese, the results
     _
of the interviews indicated that the mastery of Chinese writing is a
     _
time-consuming process, compared with the efficiency in learning the Modern
     _
Literal Taiwanese.    The results of the critical analysis suggested that the Modern
     _
Literal Taiwanese is potentially constructive to the formation of a native-
     _
Taiwanese ethnic identity among the Taiwanese people; it provides with a
     _
channel for the native speakers of Taiwanese to express their feelings and
UP
thoughts freely, and help preserve their native language and culture through
     _
writing.    Also, it is more efficient in modern communication systems and is
     _
more effective in terms of functional literacy, compared with the traditional
     _
Chinese writing in Taiwan.
UP


1. Statement of the Problem
  ___
I.I   Introduction

____This thesis investigated the potential impact of a modern literal Taiwanese in
____
Latin alphabet on the ethnic identity and communication of the Taiwanese
____
people.
____
____The problems defined and discussed in this thesis were developed through
____
the following statements:
UP



____
____1.)  A language without a formal or unified written form needs a writing
____
____systemwhich can well convey the sound and sense of that language and
____
____therefore preserveit linguistically and culturally.
____
____2.)  A collective consciousness on ethnic identity among a particular
____
____linguisticgroup might be induced through the inferior situation of their
____
____mother tongue, whichis culturally and politically stressed under an official
____
____language policy.
____
____3.) Linguistic acculturation and assimilation of the official language might
____
____happenin that linguistic group; and the mother tongue might face a danger
____
____ofdisorganization and oblivion.
____
____4.) The mother tongue at this instance might serve or can be manipulated as
UP
____a  symbool of ethnic consciousness (Ross, in Giles and Saint-Jacquers, 1979,
____
____p.10) of the linguistic group against the ruling authority symbolized by the
____
____official language.
____
____5.) If there has been no unified writing system for the native language of that
____
____linguistic group, a scientific writing system of that native language will be
____
____expected to serve as an effective and efficient medium of that linguistic
____
____group for internal and external written communications.
____
____6.) The new writing system will be expected to be processed through
____
____modern communication systems efficiently and economically.
UP


____
____The "native language of a particular linguistic group" indicated above is
____
the Banlaam (also Hoklo, or Min-nan in Mandarin) language in Taiwan,which
____
is generally referred to as the Taiwanese language. The "particular linguistic
____
group" here refers to people whose mother tongue is the Taiwanese_language;
____
the official language is Mandarin.
____
____The writing system of the Taiwanese language discussed in this thesis was
____
based on an alphabetical writing system advocated by Keahioong Liim, a
UP
professor of chemistry in National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan.
____
____In this chapter, the significance of the problem addressed how this writing
____
system might play a role as a medium of written communication of the
____
Taiwanese language andhow it might help reform the Taiwanese language and
____
native culture, both of which might further foster a more native-oriented identity
____
among the Taiwanese people. Also, as thiswriting system is alphabetical and is
____
without any additional diacritical signs marking thetones, the data processing
____
based on-it requires only touch-typing skill, which is recognizedas the fastest, the
____
most accurate and relaxed way of data input (Unger, 1987, p.65); therefore, this
____
thesis also discussed this writing system in terms of its potential in modern
____
computerized data communications, which plays an important role and will
____
become evenmore important in the future in any industrialized society.
UP


1.2  The Definition of the Problem

1.2-1 Taiwanese and Its Chinese Writing

____All dialects spoken in China or other geographical regions with population
____
of Chinese descendants are generally referred as "Chinese."    But the term
____
"Chinese" is anumbrella designation for at least eight present-day varieties of
____
mutually unintelligiblelanguages; this situation is parallel to the various languages
____
that make up the Romancegroup of languages (DeFrancis, 1989, P.94). And just
____
as these varieties of speech are  mutually unintelligible, so are the varieties of
____
written language based on them (DeFrancis,1989, p.95).   It is a myth that
____
Chinese characters cut across boundaries of speech; the reality of Chinese writing
____
is that the characters have been created by speakers of many differentvarieties of
____
dialects and often reflect the peculiarities of their speech (DeFrancis, 1989,p.95).
____
Therefore, even though the Mandarin dialect has been the official language of
____
both Taiwan and China in the basis of writing, it takes more efforts for a
____
non-native speaker of Mandarin, such as a Cantonese, to learn to read and write
____
in the national standard than it does for a Spaniard to learn to read and write
____
French (DeFrancis 1984a in DeFrancis,1989, p.95).   The Taiwanese language,
____
which originates from the Banlaam (Min-nan, Southern Min ) language,
____
accordingly has its unique Sino-writing in harnji (Han ) characters. These harnji
____
characters were borrowed from the ancient northern Haxn language to code
____
the pronunciations of many southern languages, including the southern Min
____
language.    But the major problem of Taiwanese is that the Sino-Taiwanese has
____
never been considered as themainstream for writing and official use in Taiwan;
____
consequently, it gradually has lost themany harnji characters uniquely used in
____
this language, although even the usage of these characters has never been
____
unified.   On the other hand, people in today's Taiwan are no longer able to use
____
this writing tp wrote Taiwanese as aform of written communication;   on the
____
other hand, Sino-Taiwanese had never been popularized because of the
____
historical and culturalbackground of Taiwan.
____


____
1.2-2 The Impact of the Official Languages

____Before the Japanese colonial period (1895-1945), literacy was generally low
____
in Taiwan. Most of the people were illiterate, for only people from well-to-do
____
families were able to go to private schools or to hire a tutor to learn to read and
____
write classical Chinese.   Poor people couldn't afford education, and women
____
were not allowed to go to school at that time.    Later, during the Japanese
____
colonial period, the official language was the Japanese language, by which mass
____
education was offered.    After World War II, the "mainlanders" and their
____
descendants (who today compose approximately 12-14% of the population in
____
Taiwan) who arrived on Taiwan in 1949 have strongly promoted Mandarin as
____
the official language (MacDonald, 1988, p. 13), by which education is offered
____
and media are dominated.
____
____It is because of the massive immigration of mainlanders after 1949 that the
____
position of the official language is so unusually strong for Taiwan, a
____
non-Mandarin-speaking region (Norman, 1988, p.248).    The mainland
____
population in Taiwan was originally associated with either the Nationalist
____
government or with the Nationalist army, and many of them had already
____
possessed a basic working knowledge of the official language Mandarin when
____
they first arrived in Taiwan (Norman, 1988, p.251).
____
       Today, most Taiwanese people can fluently speak and write Mandarin in
____
any official occasion; the adult literacy in Taiwan was 95% in 1985 (MacDonald,
____
1988, p. 14).    However, Taiwanese is still the major tongue of people's daily
____
communication underinformal settings and in closer relations, despite the great
____
progress in promoting the official language which has been made in the last thirty
____
years (Norman, 1988, p.248).    But inmetropolitan areas, notably the capital
____
Taipei, a large number of people under forty years of age, in the course of
____
growing up and especially as a result of their schooling, haveabandoned or
____
forgotten their non-standard family dialects (including Taiwanese and other
____
dialects) acquired in their infancy and have switched to the official language
____
Mandarin astheir sole means of oral communication (Norman, 1988, p.251). In
____
some young familieschildren have begun to learn Mandarin as their first
____
language, and in effect these children become native speakers of this standard
____
language (Norman, 1988, p.251).
____


1.2-3  The Role of the Taiwanese Language in the Democratic Movements --- How It Serves As a Symbol of Ethnic Consciousness
____
____Before the 1986 democratic reform, public discussion and criticism about
____
the language policy had long been a political taboo in Taiwan.   The democratic
____
reform since 1986 in Taiwan has launched a more native-orientedideology
____
among the Taiwanese people than before;   this includes the struggle for civil
____
rights, the awareness of environmental protection, the reform of native
____
Taiwanese culture,and the equality of language distribution in media use.
____
These sense of consciousness and the resulting actions consequently evoke
____
public concern about the very medium of communication -- the long belittled
____
Taiwanese language, which many reform-mindedpeople saw as a symbol of
____
native consciousness and an emblem and fortress preservingTaiwanese culture.
____
____In some cases of democratic movements, especially in the issue of
____
independency,the Taiwanese language is viewed as a symbol of native ethnic
____
consciousness (Ross, in Giles and Saint-Jacques, 1979, p. 10) in contrast to the
____
Sino-centric ideology imposed by the ruling authority and symbolized by the
____
official language Mandarin.
____


1.2-4   Ideographic Writing in Computerized Data ProcessingSystems
____
____ As Mandarin Chinese is the official language in Taiwan, the writing based
____
on it accordingly is the standard form of written communication.    Chinese
____
typewriters, wordprocessors, and especially computational systems have been
____
produced or developed to deal with jobs associated with data processing in
____
offices and families.    It is common, however,that the users of these data
____
processing systems get both mentally and physically stressed (Unger, 1987, p.
____
129) with their jobs done inefficiently.    This is because of the complex and
____
time-consuming process of inputting the large number of complex ideographic
____
Chinesecharacters.
____
____Generally, there are three different ways commonly used in today's Taiwan
____
to input Chinese characters into computers. ___One is a word-structuring
____
package called "Tsang Chieh ."  To complete a text, the operators using this
____
program construct the Chinese harnjicharacters by typing different parts of the
____
characters from a special keyboard with small parts of characters.    If the user
____
doesn't know the ideographic composure of a word, he or she has to interrupt
____
to look up the composure of the word or just fail to complete the typing if no
____
source of reference is available.
____
____Another way to input harnji characters is an extension of Chinese
____
dictionaries thatdivided harnji characters into different families under different
____
radicals.    To input a single character, the user first has to know which radical
____
this character belongs to.    The biggest problem of this program is that very few
____
people know the radicals of every hamji character, including those who are
____
mastering Chinese literature and language.   Most people know little about which
____
characters belong to which radicals.
____
____The most commonly used program in Chinese computational data
____
processing systems in Taiwan needs a special keyboard with symbols for
____
phonetic notations of Mandarin Chinese (in Mandarin the zhu`yi^nfu'ha`o )
____
(Norman, 1988, p.259).   When typing a Chinese text on a computer using this
____
program, the user has to type the phonetic combination of a particular word, then
____
press the "enter" or "return" command on the keyboard.   When finished, there is
____
a series of Chinese hamji characters representing this phonetic combination
____
appearing at the bottom of the screen with Arabic numerals indicating each single
____
character.    What the user has to do is select the numeral indicating the right
____
character.    If the user cannot find the right character, he or she has to press the
____
"enter" or "return" command again and again, till the right character appears.
____
After finishing allthese steps, the processing of a single hamji character is
____
completed and that single character appears and located in the writer's text on the
____
screen.    The major problem of this word program is that in Mandarin Chinese
____
there are too many homophones sharing the same phonetic combination (Liim,
____
1992, p.23); this takes the users much time and labor to complete data processing
____
character by character.    Moreover, it also bothers those who are not able to
____
pronounce Mandarin correctly.____
____
____The three methods used in Chinese computerized data processing described
____
aboveare time-consuming, and mentally and physically stress the users (Unger,
____
1987, p. 129).   Economically, on the other hand, computational data processing
____
costs more to output information written in ideographic than in alphanumeric
____
form because of the large numberof the ideographic characters and their graphic
____
complexity (Unger, 1987, p. 129).    The extraexpense comes from a need for a
____
high-resolution video monitor or printer, extra memoryfor storing the hamji
____
characters, longer plotting times, fewer characters per page, or someother
____
hardware-related factors (Unger, 1987, p. 129).
____
____This thesis, therefore, explored the potential of the moderm literal Taiwanese,
____
a Latin alphabetical writing system which can well convey both the sound and
____
sense of the Taiwanese language.    It is not an instruction of this writing system,
____
but an investigation of why it is important for the Taiwanese people and their
____
culture, how it can serve as an instrument of identity change, as well as how it
____
can help people communicate more conveniently and efficiently in an
____
increasingly technology-based society.
____


1.3  The Significance of the Problem
____
____Language is a primary tool of human communication;  and the written form
____
of a particular language is the most important medium to preserve this language,
____
both linguistically and culturally.   Therefore, the investigation of the potential
____
impact of theModern Literal Taiwanese is significant in the study of human
____
communication.    This studyexplored how the ethnic identity of an
____
ethnolinguistic group can be evoked, shaped, andeven manipulated through the
____
written form of the mother tongue of that group, which haslong been depressed
____
under a special historical and political setting;   how this written form of the
____
mother tongue might influence people's daily communication;   and finally, how
____
this Latin alphabetical writing system, being unencumbered with diacritical
____
marks, can beperfectly processed through any computational data processing
____
systems just like English or any other European languages.
____


1.3-1   The Significance of Language and Cultural Reform
____
____Under the system of the Modern Literal Taiwanese, the spelling of each
____
single wordcorresponds rather precisely to the pronunciation of this word as a
____
whole, and is no morethan the simple combination of the phonetic
____
representation of the constructing harnji characters (Liim, 1988).    It is
____
alphabetical;   and no additional phonetic signs is used in this system (See
____
Appendix 1).    For example, hoesoaan-ym, the circling-around vowels uniquein
____
Taiwanese, are represented in the forms as "aa," "ii," "uu," "ee," "oo," "oo,"
____
"mm," and "ngg."   This method of word spelling enables people to learn the
____
spoken Taiwanese by memorizing words by spelling, and to write sentences
____
using an ordinary typewriter or a word processor (Liim, 1988).
____
____From the point of view of reforming the native language and culture, this
____
writing system is potentially significant to the Taiwanese people for the following
____
reasons:


____
____*  First, scince Taiwanese is quite different from Mandarin in pronunciation,
____
____literalusage, and grammatical syntax  ---  actually, in the linguistic terms, the
____
____two languages belong to different families  ---  this writing system will
____
____provide the native speakers of Taiwanese with a channel to emancipate their
____
____inner feelings and thoughts withoutthe distortion and difficulty in using the
____
____official Chinese writing, which is grammatically syntaxed and literally
____
____composed in Mandarin.
____
____*  Second, with this writing system, folk ballads and anecdotes transmitted
____
____orally can be effectively preserved with their original style and emphasis.
____
____On the other hand, with literature and a formal written form, the Taiwanese
____
____language can be better preserved without the distortion and disorganization
____
____caused by long-termmisuse.    In this regard both the Taiwanese language
____
____itself and the literature or arts associated with this language can be preserved
____
____by its written form both linguistically and culturally.
____

1.3-2   The Significance of the Impact on Ethnic Identity
____
____Since the Taiwanese language, as has been discussed formerly, plays the role
____
as a symbol of ethnic consciousness (Ross, in Giles and Saint-Jacques, 1979, p.
____
10) in thedemocratic movements in Taiwan, accordingly, a writing system which
____
can well serve as a medium of written communication of the language will play a
____
part as the visible symbol of the ethnic consciousness of the Taiwanese people.
____
Also, it may socio-culturally and psychologically build a collective identity
____
among the Taiwanese people within the contextof native culture in terms of the
____
cultural significance of writing in preserving a language.
____
____Language, together with ethnicity, are basic elements of the identity
____
and individuality of a human being (Saint-Jacques and Giles, 1979).   Moreover,
____
since languageis a part of the codified culture (Schramm and Porter, 1982, p.81)
____
and the unifying factorof a particular culture (Saint-Jacques and Giles, 1979),
____
and whereas writing codes language, this modern literal Taiwanese might
____
spontaneously awaken a more native-oriented identity among the Taiwanese
____
people.    This spontaneous awareness might happenwhen the Taiwanese people
____
are acculturated under the literal orientation of the written Taiwanese language.
____
This is because written language is not only a derivative symbolsystem enjoying
____
only a parasitic status with respect to oral language (Scinto, 1986, p. 1) but also
____
a culturally organized function or system subject to learning and development
____
(Scinto,1986, p-77).    Also, language itself is a dynamic force in the unfolding
____
progression of group interaction and identity formation (Ross, in Giles and
____
Saint-Jacques, 1979, p.ll);   it isimportant as a symbol of an underlying image of
____
group purpose and identity, and in this regard, it is the most powerful single
____
symbol of ethnicity because it serves as a shorthandfor all that makes a group
____
special and unique (Ross, in Giles and Saint-Jacques, 1979,P.9).
____


1.3-3   The Significance of Efficient Computerized Data Communications
____
____The use of data communications through computers is expected to
____
increase tremendously in the future (Liim, 1990a, p.5).   Actually, the past decade
____
has witnessed aboom in computer data communications, which enables
____
computers and their operators to "talk" in highly efficient networks (Duffy, 1992,
____
p. 170).    The highly efficient datacommunications through computers requires
____
efficient input, which combines the speed and accuracy of data input with the
____
minimum of physical and mental stress of users on man/machine interface, and
____
output, which seeks minimum hardware costs (Ungjfer, 1987,p. 129).   Those
____
languages with a large number of ideographic characters such as Chinese and
____
Japanese, however are not well suited for efficient and convenient input and
____
output of dataprocessing owing to the complex and large number of ideographic
____
characters (Unger,1987, p.64).    Therefore, in order to achieve efficient data
____
communication, in Japan Romaji(the Romanized writing) and kana have been
____
widely used in data communication systems instead of kanji (this term is
____
equivalent to hamji characters) (Unger, 1987, p. 19).    China has also been
____
promoting writing reforms such as alphabetization and simplification of
____
characters in Mandarin Chinese since the early twentieth century (Norman, 1988,
____
p.262).   However, in terms of alphabetization of characters, there is an
____
unsolvable problem in the Mandarin language itself:   the large number of
____
homophones sharing the same spellings,which has caused ambiguieties among
____
characters for a particular pronunciation (Liim,1990a, p.58; andHsu, in VIST,
____
1991, p. 195).   On the other hand, for thousands of years Taiwanese has
____
primarily served as an oral language;   therefore, the articulation and
____
pronunciation of this language is very slightlydistinguished by the speakers to
____
avoid miscommunication (Liim, 1990a, p.4).    As a result,there are very few
____
homophones in this language and, therefore, the phonetic ambiguieties which
____
Mandarin has suffered in data processing can be avoided (Liim, 1990a, p.4,
____
p.58). Accordingly, this alphabetical writing system is potentially superior to
____
the traditional ideographic harnji characters in terms of efficiency and economy
____
in data processing, which is crucial in today's technology-based society and the
____
arena ofinternational competition.    It can be efficiently processed through
____
computers, word processors, or just ordinary typewriters like English or other
____
European languages and can save time and labor.    Moreover, the additional
____
demands on hardware to code and outputharnji characters will be unnecessary.
____


1.3-4   The Significance of Efficient Language Learning and Functional Literacy
____
____As spelling makes the learning of written language easier and therefore
____
enables literacy more funcionary applied than memorizing the graphic structures
____
of ideographic characters (Liim, 1990a, p4). the Modern Literal Taiwanese is
____
expected to help Taiwanese learn the writing of their native language efficiently.
____
Also. it will provided anyone who wants to learn this language with a reliable
____
and efficient sourse of learning.
________
____The impact of the Modern Literal Taiwanese on the Taiwanese people is
____
potentially significant in both communication and socio-cultural levels.   In terms
____
of communication, on the one hand, the writing system will enable the native
____
speakers of Taiwanese to express their inner thoughts and feelings and makes the
____
learning of written Taiwanese efficient and convenient.   On the other hand, as
____
computers and technology will be used tremendously in any work place, family,
____
business, and industry in the future (Liim, 1990a, p.5), it is, therefore, crucial for
____
any society to have efficient and economical data processing systems to be
____
competent in international competition.
____
____And socio-culturally, it will keep the Taiwanese language itself
____
from disorganization and distortion.   It will also preserve the folk literature,
____
which is culturally important, from oblivion.   Lastly, it might serve as a medium
____
of written communication for the Taiwanese language, which, politically, is a
____
symbol of ethnic consciousness (Ross, inGiles and Saint-Jacques, 1979, p. 10) in
____
many Taiwanese democratic movements.   InTaiwan today more and more
____
people are looking forward to a more democratic political environment with a
____
more native Taiwan-oriented ideology; while the issue of independency has been
____
highly debatable and controversial, it is interesting to investigate how and why
____
this writing system might impact the ethnic identity among the Taiwanese people.
____



Chapter 2   Literature Review
____2.1 The Taiwanese Language
____2.2 The Evolution of the Reform of Written Taiwanese
____2.3 The Role of Mother Tongue in Human Communication
____2.4 Language and Ethnic Identity
____2.5 The Role of the Taiwanese Language in the Context of
________Ethnicity
____2.6 The Importance of Writing in Cultural Context
____2.7 Native Languages Written down
____2.8 Writing Vs. Data Processing
____2.9 Summary
____
____

Chapter 3   Methodology
____3.1 Research Design
____3.2 Research Procedure
____3.3 Plan for Analysis
____
____

Chapter 4   Results of the Interviews
____4.1 Background of the Interviews
____4.2 Description of the Interviews
____
____

Chapter 5   Analysis and Conclusion
____5.1 The Modern Literal Taiwanese and the Ethnic Identity
________of the Taiwanese people
____5.1 The Modern Literal Taiwanese and the Communication
________of the Taiwanese people
____5.3 Summary of the Conclusions
____
____

Chapter 6   Discussion
____6.1 Overview of the Research
____6.2 Limitation of the Research
____6.3 Directions for Future Research